A preview of new NPI data on how agencies are staffing the strategy, and solutions that help you plan the hours and get more from your hot spots time.
The Big Picture
Hot spots policing cuts crime, and NPI believes it also offers workload benefits and efficiency gains for agencies that plan for it, but many agencies may not be realizing this value.
Every law enforcement leader knows crime clusters in a few places. Hot spots policing deploys officers to targeted places, rather than waiting to respond to calls after they come in. It is one of the most tested strategies in policing that centers on a trade: invest in officer time preventing crime in identified places in return for fewer calls to respond to later.
A forthcoming NPI national assessment shows how widely agencies use it. Of 56 medium and large agencies that responded to an NPI survey, 54 use hot spots policing, and most of those have used it for more than five years. Yet few have written their hot spots policing practices into policy or can verify that officers deliver it, and most name staffing as their top barrier to implementing it.
This month’s InFocus article previews those assessment findings, explains why the staffing problem is also a workload problem, and points to where agencies can start. NPI has studied how agencies put this strategy into practice, and we have more to share than one article can hold. Our full results are expected to be released next month.
What the Evidence Shows
The research says hot spots policing is worth doing well. NPI’s new data show where agencies fall short.
Hot spots policing reduces crime where it is applied, and fewer crimes should mean fewer calls. A Campbell Collaboration review found noteworthy crime and disorder reductions in 62 of 78 tests, and benefits spread to nearby areas more often than crime moved away (Braga et al., 2019). In Dallas, violent crime fell 11% in targeted hot spots in the first year of the city’s crime plan, with no sign of displacement (Smith et al., 2024). In a trial in Hamilton County, Ohio, crime-related calls fell 23% in treated hot spots in the first year, compared to a 16% decline in comparison hot spots (Haberman et al., 2025). For a law enforcement leader, the crime reduction benefits of hot spots policing are settled and reduced demand on officer time is a reasoned expectation, not a wish.
Awareness of hot spots policing is robust, with 95% of agencies in the national assessment reporting they are “very familiar” with the strategy. Nearly every participating agency uses hot spots policing, but far fewer have built the systems that maximize its effectiveness or provide the ability to optimize outcomes. Of the 54 agencies that use it, 70% run it as a formal, agency-wide strategy and 63% have done so for more than five years. Notably, only 21% write expectations into policy. Further, 19% suggest their officers receive no formal training on it. A program that lives in a law enforcement executive’s list of priorities instead of in policy is exposed to every budget cut and changes in command.
Additionally, the assessment reports only 57% of agencies set a time target for officers in hot spots and few agencies can reliably confirm that officers are meeting formal time targets. Dosage is often an informal guideline. Directed patrol is the main deployment activity as 96% of responding agencies use it, and 79% call it their most frequent activity. Problem-oriented strategies, which research finds adds to the effect of patrol alone (Braga et al., 2019; Turchan & Braga, 2024), is an underutilized approach to enhancing crime reduction benefits.
Staffing is a main barrier, and it is a workload problem as much as a headcount problem. Of responding agencies, 72% name insufficient staffing as their top challenge to implementing hot spots policing, and 47% say staffing and time constraints “often limit their agency’s ability to conduct hot spots policing as intended”. The research-based staffing standard is demanding. Known as the Koper Curve, visits of about 10 to 15 minutes build residual deterrence (Koper, 1995), where visibility rather than enforcement, is the driver of the effect. Consider an agency that sets a dose of two hours a day at each hot spot, delivered in 15-minute visits. Ten hot spots at that dose require 20 officer-hours every day. This ultimately is a staffing planning question, rather than a question of officer effort. Interviewees from NPI’s assessment said patrol is often so absorbed by calls for service that dosage, or officer time at hot spots, can be the first thing to slip, especially in instances where officers see the assignment as “one more thing” rather than a core component of their job.
What Every Agency Can Do Now
Four things should happen if an agency wants to optimize the crime benefits of their hot spots policing efforts and increase staffing efficiency.
- Know what hot spots policing costs in officer-hours. Hot spots work needs planned time, and few agencies have counted it against the patrol hours left after calls for service. Agency staffing decisions cannot account for it if it is unknown.
- Institutionalize hot spots expectations in policy and embed them in accountability structures. Only 21% of agencies put it in policy, and more than half (53%) verify implementation at hot spots by officer self-report rather than formal tracking mechanisms. A strategy that is neither written down nor consistently and formally checked will ultimately be less effective.
- Close the dosage gap. Establish time-in-hot-spot targets consistent with the short, intermittent-visit standard the research supports (the Koper Curve) and ensure officers are meeting those targets.
- Direct more proactive time to where crime concentrates. Many agencies have some time not committed to calls, and the research suggests it can be used better.
Agencies differ significantly in how they can do each of these. A department of 10 officers and a department of 1,000 will approach the same tasks with different assets, tools, and risks. That is where NPI can help.
The Bottom Line
Hot spots policing works, and nearly every responding agency in NPI’s national landscape assessment uses it. Many are not getting its full value, because agency approaches don’t always align with what is needed. Policy, training, and tracking are lacking, and staffing limits the time spent in targeted areas. Part of that can be addressed by planning the hours, verifying delivery, and ensuring proactive officer time is spent where crime concentrates. The exact amount of workload that agencies can save by taking these actions is not easily guaranteed. Agencies that commit to assessing and measuring will find out the reality of workload benefits, otherwise they will keep paying for a strategy they cannot verify. Agencies generally know where crime concentrates. The question remains whether they plan the hours and deploy officers to effectively address those concentrations.
How NPI Can Help
If you want to talk through staffing, workload, and hot spots implementation support, NPI’s technical assistance and research teams can help. Many agencies find the first step, developing a clear picture of where officer hours go, hard to do alone. We can work with your agency to understand those hours, examine how closely your hot spots practice matches the research, and what your options are before you add or move personnel. We start with your own data and develop findings so your command staff can act. Our staffing studies take these considerations into account and are designed with research evidence as a foundation, and our soon-to-be-released staffing product will allow users to adjust proactivity levels to better utilize shift hours. Results from an NPI staffing study and soon-to-be-released staffing app will help agencies identify whether and when officers have time for directed patrol in hot spots and how to make more effective staffing decisions.
References
Braga, A. A., Papachristos, A. V., & Hureau, D. M. (2014). The effects of hot spots policing on crime: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Justice Quarterly, 31(4), 633-663. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2012.673632
Braga, A. A., Turchan, B., Papachristos, A. V., & Hureau, D. M. (2019). Hot spots policing of small geographic areas effects on crime. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 15(3), e1046. https://doi.org/10.1002/cl2.1046
Haberman, C. P., O’Guinn, B. J., McGrath, M., Kumavat, A. V., & Orue, A. (2025). A randomized controlled trial of a hot spots policing initiative in suburban and rural areas. Justice Evaluation Journal, 8(2), 187–204. https://doi.org/10.1080/24751979.2025.2475352
Koper, C. S. (1995). Just enough police presence: Reducing crime and disorderly behavior by optimizing patrol time in crime hot spots. Justice Quarterly, 12(4), 649-672. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418829500096231
Smith, M. R., Tillyer, R., & Tregle, B. (2024). Hot spots policing as part of a city-wide violent crime reduction strategy: Initial evidence from Dallas. Journal of Criminal Justice, 90.
Turchan, B., & Braga, A. A. (2024). The effects of hot spots policing on violence: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 79, 102011.
Never miss an issue of InFocus
Share